麻豆淫院


Misusing ecology: Study warns against comparing human migration to biological invasions

Study warns against comparing human migration to biological  invasions
Flowering individual of the Himalayan balsam Impatiens glandulifera, an ornamental plant introduced to Europe from Asia in 1840, where it escaped from botanical gardens into surrounding areas, and has since established dense populations. Image by U. Kutschera. Credit: Biological Reviews (2025). DOI: 10.1111/brv.70004

A new study in Biological Reviews critically examines the parallels and key differences between human migration and biological invasions. Bringing together experts from both the natural and social sciences, the study explains why drawing such parallels is misleading and potentially harmful, particularly in today's politically charged climate.

The study was led by Dr. Danish Ahmed (Gulf University for Science & Technology, Kuwait) and Dr. Phillip Haubrock (Senckenberg Research Institute, Germany).

While both human migration and involve movement, establishment, and integration into new environments, they occur under vastly different circumstances. Biological invasions are studied largely within ecological frameworks, focusing on species dispersal, competition, and , whereas human migration is shaped by complex social, political, environmental and historical factors that may also apply to biological invasions.

The study warns that applying invasion science terminology, such as "alien," "invasive," or "eradication" to migration oversimplifies the issue, reinforcing xenophobic narratives and distorting public perceptions of displaced people.

The researchers highlight how has repeatedly misused invasion-related language to frame migration as a threat. By examining historical case studies, ethical considerations, and socio-political influences, the study reveals how misleading comparisons can dehumanize migrants and obscure the true drivers of migration.

Unlike biological invasions, which can cause severe ecological and socioeconomic impacts, migration, despite always having been an integral part of human history, is inherently more complex with numerous nuances and facets making an evaluation more complicated. The researchers stress that migration policies should be guided by evidence and ethical considerations, rather than alarmist narratives rooted in misapplied ecological concepts.

To challenge these misconceptions, the study advocates for a more integrative, that bridges natural and social sciences. Policies concerning both human migration and biological invasions must be context-specific, scientifically rigorous, and grounded in ethical principles. By fostering a clearer and more informed discourse, this research paves the way for policymaking that promotes while upholding human dignity and global cooperation.

More information: Danish A. Ahmed et al, Parallels and discrepancies between non鈥恘ative species introductions and human migration, Biological Reviews (2025).

Journal information: Biological Reviews

Provided by Gulf University for Science and Technology

Citation: Misusing ecology: Study warns against comparing human migration to biological invasions (2025, February 24) retrieved 25 August 2025 from /news/2025-02-misusing-ecology-human-migration-biological.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Nonnative plants are a major force behind global insect invasions, study finds

0 shares

Feedback to editors