Âé¶¹ÒùÔº

February 19, 2025

Socially dominant individuals are more confident but not necessarily more competent, finds study

Two bird statistical learning task. Note. Participants were required to select which of two birds would be presented next. Credit: Personality and Individual Differences (2025). DOI: 10.1016/j.paid.2024.113037
× close
Two bird statistical learning task. Note. Participants were required to select which of two birds would be presented next. Credit: Personality and Individual Differences (2025). DOI: 10.1016/j.paid.2024.113037

Research from the University of Kent's School of Psychology has found that people who strive for dominance, whether in personal or professional life, are more confident in their decision-making but are no more accurate in their choices than those of a lower social status.

The research, by the journal Personality and Individual Differences, challenges the idea that confidence signals competence, a perception that often propels dominant individuals into leadership roles.

Led by Dr. Andrew Martin, the research found that was comparable between males and females and both showed an effect of greater confidence, debunking the long-held belief that dominance-driven strategies are primarily male traits.

Dr. Martin said, "While high status within is often associated with socially dominant individuals, our research goes to show that there is no superiority in decision performance and why acting confidently can actually be an effective social strategy, regardless of ability. Our findings uncover how socially dominant individuals may traverse society, acquire and possibly even retain positions of social power and influence."

To reach their conclusions, the psychologists assessed the performance of participants through three studies using a two-choice statistical learning task and a self-referential memory task.

More information: A. Belotelova et al, Confidence does not equal competence: Socially dominant individuals are more confident in their decisions without being more accurate, Personality and Individual Differences (2025).

Journal information: Personality and Individual Differences

Provided by University of Kent

Load comments (0)

This article has been reviewed according to Science X's and . have highlighted the following attributes while ensuring the content's credibility:

fact-checked
peer-reviewed publication
trusted source
proofread

Get Instant Summarized Text (GIST)

Individuals with a drive for social dominance exhibit higher confidence in decision-making but do not demonstrate greater accuracy compared to those of lower social status. This challenges the notion that confidence equates to competence. The effect of increased confidence was observed equally in both males and females, suggesting that dominance-driven strategies are not gender-specific. Despite their confidence, socially dominant individuals do not outperform others in decision tasks.

This summary was automatically generated using LLM.