Climate cost of global trawling still uncertain
The amount of carbon released by seabed fishing worldwide is uncertain and must be urgently investigated, researchers say.
Convex Seascape Survey scientists are studying the impact of fishing methods that use towed nets dragged along the seafloor, such as trawling and dredging.
These methods are the main way that humans disturb ocean sediments鈥攖he world's largest reservoir of organic carbon鈥攂ut there is disagreement about the amount of carbon these methods release.
The new study, led by researchers at the University of Exeter and in Fish and Fisheries, begins to untangle this mystery.
"To find out how much carbon is being released by these fishing methods, we need to know how much of the seabed is actually being disturbed," said Mollie Rickwood, from the Center for Ecology and Conservation on Exeter's Penryn Campus in Cornwall.
"The best data available is from European fishing vessels, and previous research has used European fishing gear metrics to estimate the area of seafloor disturbed globally.
"Our main finding is that vessel and gear sizes vary a lot from country to country鈥攕o using European data to make global estimates is likely to lead to large inaccuracies in the amount of the seafloor trawled, and therefore how much carbon could be released to the atmosphere."
The new paper demonstrates the need for good regional data on the size of fishing vessels and gear, to allow accurate estimates of seafloor disturbance.
Get free science updates with Science X Daily and Weekly Newsletters 鈥 to customize your preferences!
"At present, this is almost impossible due to the big European bias in existing data, as well as a lack of standardized reporting of fishing gear," Rickwood continued.
"Our paper is a 'call to arms' to address these knowledge gaps and encourage global collaboration between science and industry to make this data available."
The Convex Seascape Survey, an ambitious five-year global research program, is the largest attempt yet to build a greater understanding of the properties and capabilities of the ocean and its continental shelves in Earth's carbon cycle in the urgent effort to slow climate change.
"Ocean carbon stores could be more secure than those on land, where forests, bogs and tundra are increasingly impacted by wildfire, flood and drought. So it is critical we understand how safe carbon is once it is locked away in the seabed," said Professor Callum Roberts of Exeter University, who leads the Convex Seascape Survey.
More information: Mollie Rickwood et al, Regional Variation in Active Bottom鈥怌ontacting Gear Footprints, Fish and Fisheries (2025).
Journal information: Fish and Fisheries
Provided by University of Exeter