Credit: Unsplash/CC0 Public Domain
Kayakers and paddleboarders enjoying Scotland's coastlines may be unknowingly disturbing marine mammals, according to new research highlighting the growing pressures faced by whales, dolphins and seals in Scottish waters.
Led by Heriot-Watt University with support from Whale and Dolphin Conservation (WDC), the published in Biological Conservation documented hundreds of interactions between vessels and marine mammals, many of which occurred in sensitive or protected areas.
More than 400 hours of land-based observations were carried out across five Scottish Marine Regions: the Clyde, Forth and Tay, Moray Firth, Orkney Islands and Shetland Isles.
Disturbances caused by kayaks and paddleboards were recorded in the Clyde, Forth and Tay, and Moray Firth.
Meanwhile, powered vessel disturbances, including those from speedboats and RIBs, occurred in every area.
The researchers behind the report caution against making direct comparisons between regions.
Dr. Emily Hague from Heriot-Watt University said, "The sightings were opportunistic, meaning they reflect what happened to be observed, not necessarily how often disturbances occur.
"Just because no incidents involving kayaks were recorded in Orkney or Shetland doesn't mean they don't happen."
Signs of disruption
Dr. Hague said, "The study focused on what happened when vessels were present at the same time as marine mammals and how the animals responded.
"Around one-third of all observed disturbance responses involved small, non-motorized craft like kayaks, paddleboards and rowboats.
"In one case, seals resting on a beach became visibly agitated as kayaks passed by, beginning to move around and then many left the haul-out site and slid into the water, a clear disruption of their resting behavior.
"Signs of stress aren't always dramatic or obvious; it can be more subtle, such as a change in breathing rate, swimming direction or their diving behavior."
Another third of recorded disturbances involved small motorboats: in one case, a speedboat repeatedly pursued bottlenose dolphins. The animals changed direction, lengthened their dives and only regrouped after the boat left.
Importantly, many of these vessels don't carry AIS (Automatic Identification System) tracking, meaning their presence and behavior are effectively invisible to regulators and conservation authorities.
Enjoy the water while minimizing harm
Dr. Hague said, "The truth is that all of Scotland's coastline is important habitat for marine mammals.
"Whether you're paddling off the coast of Fife or sailing around Skye, you're likely sharing the water with sensitive species.
"We want people to enjoy Scotland's waters, but to do so responsibly by keeping up to date on how best to respond should you spot marine wildlife.
"Kayakers, paddleboarders, surfers, recreational boaters and everyone else in the water should follow the , which offers clear advice on how to minimize your impact on marine mammals.
"With a little more awareness and a few small changes, we can all help ensure that sharing the sea doesn't come at a cost to the animals that call it home."
More information: Emily Hague et al, Marine monitors: Land-based citizen science observations show AIS data underrepresents coastal vessel traffic co-occurring with marine mammals, Biological Conservation (2025).
Journal information: Biological Conservation
Provided by Heriot-Watt University