Âé¶¹ÒùÔº


Beyond the alpha male: Primate studies challenge male-dominance norms

Beyond the alpha male
Two chacma baboons in a fight, the male on the right attacking a female. In this species, males are twice as large as females, and males are dominant over females. Credit: Alecia Carter

New findings by researchers at the University of Montpellier, the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology in Leipzig, and the German Primate Center in Göttingen resolve why male-female power asymmetries vary across primate societies.

The work is in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

Bringing together detailed observations of male-female aggression from 253 populations across 121 , the study shows that clear-cut by either sex is rare, and highlights the conditions under which females have become socially dominant over males in primate evolutionary history.

Intersexual conflicts are common

The comprehensive review of available data on intersexual aggression revealed that contests between males and females are surprisingly common.

On average, almost half of the aggressive interactions in involved a male and a female. Previous research mostly focused on fights among individuals of the same sex, because existing theories in assume that males and females compete over different resources.

"The observation that in most populations any given individual is more likely to be involved in a fight against another individual of the opposite rather than the same sex highlights that the battle of the sexes is common in other animals," says Dieter Lukas from the Max Planck Institute for Evolutionary Anthropology.

The study goes on to analyze the outcome of such contests: are they most often won by males or by females, and does this proportion vary across species?

Beyond the alpha male
Two redfronted lemurs peeking out of a tree, a male on the left and a female on the right. In this species, males are the same size as females, and females are dominant over males. Credit: Claudia Fichtel

It was long assumed that power tends to be biased towards males in primates, and that the few emblematic female-dominant species, like ring-tailed lemurs or bonobos, represented an exception requiring special explanation.

Instead, the new study reveals the complexity and variability of sex biases in dominance relations in primate societies.

As Peter Kappeler, from the German Primate Center, notes, "Recent research started to challenge the traditional views of male dominance being the default status, and our study now provides a more comprehensive exploration of variation in intersexual dominance relationships."

In their sample, the clear dominance of males, where they win more than 90% of contests over females, was observed in only 25 of the 151 populations with quantitative data. Clear female dominance was observed in 16 populations, leaving 70% of the populations with moderate or no sex-biases in power.

Beyond the alpha male
A group of chacma baboons in the middle of a grooming session. On the left, the larger male has his fur cleaned by a smaller female with a baby. In this species, males are dominant over females. Credit: Élise Huchard

Implications for understanding gender relationships

The research team tested five hypotheses to explain sex biases in dominance relations, and found that female-biased dominance is associated with several key factors.

Female power is mostly seen in species in which females are monogamous, of similar size as males, or primarily forage in trees—all situations in which females have more choice in whether or not to mate with a particular male.

In addition, female dominance is also facilitated in situations where females face intense competition over resources, such as in solitary or pair-living species, as well as when male-female conflicts are less risky for their dependent offspring, for example, because mothers park offspring when they forage instead of carrying them around with them.

Conversely, male-biased dominance prevails in species that are terrestrial, where males have larger bodies or weapons than females, and where males mate with multiple females.

"Critically, while primate males gain power via and coercion, female empowerment relies on alternative pathways, such as reproductive strategies to gain control over matings," explains Elise Huchard from the University of Montpellier.

The study's findings have important implications for our understanding of the evolution of social behavior across animals, and may also shed some light on our understanding of human social dynamics.

The finding that it is almost as likely that females dominate males than the reverse, and that most primate societies do not have clear-cut sex-biases in power, challenges traditional views of the natural origins of gender roles.

Humans do not share all the traits that characterize species where males strictly dominate females. Instead, the set of human traits places them closer to species, showing more nuanced relationships, where individuals of either sex can become dominant.

Accordingly, arguments presenting human patriarchy as a primate legacy appear misguided, and gender relations should be considered in relation to their social and ecological contexts.

More information: Huchard, Elise et al, The evolution of male–female dominance relations in primate societies, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (2025). .

Provided by Max Planck Society

Citation: Beyond the alpha male: Primate studies challenge male-dominance norms (2025, July 7) retrieved 17 July 2025 from /news/2025-07-alpha-male-primate-dominance-norms.html
This document is subject to copyright. Apart from any fair dealing for the purpose of private study or research, no part may be reproduced without the written permission. The content is provided for information purposes only.

Explore further

Male power over females is not the default social dynamic in primates, says study

99 shares

Feedback to editors