Chemical safety analysis: (A) current analytical techniques with shortcomings for product safety; (B) metaphoric comparison with the art of painting for interpretation of the chemical space revealed by the different techniques; (C) the open questions highlight the need for a proactive safety screening (already existing but overlooked). Credit: Journal of Chromatography A (2025). DOI: 10.1016/j.chroma.2025.465946
Four new studies by scientists from Justus Liebig University Giessen (JLU) have shown that lifestyle products contain hazardous compounds that have not been detected by previous tests and are not currently regulated. The researchers used a new analytical methodology to investigate 140 skincare products and cosmetics from 20 product segments as well as more than 40 perfumes.
They found hazardous compounds that are mutagenic/genotoxic, cytotoxic, antibacterial, neuromodulatory or neurotoxic, and significantly affect the hormonal balance. A possible detoxification of the hazardous compounds in the body was not evident from a simulated liver metabolism. Their studies were published in the Journal of Chromatography A and Analytica Chimica Acta.
The newly developed methodology of the JLU scientists enables the discovery of unknown hazardous compounds in these complex products and simultaneously examines their effect on cells and receptors. This means that a toxin does not have to be known in order to see its effect. Previously unknown hazardous compounds can be ingredients, but also contaminants, impurities, and degradation products.
"We have expanded the current substance separation with effect detection and can now see for the first time how many hazardous compounds are present in such everyday products," explains Prof. Dr. Gertrud Morlock, Professor of Food Science at JLU. "Complex substance groups such as mineral oils include substances with different toxicities, which can lead to completely different effects with the same amount but different representatives of this substance group.
"With previous analytical methods, substances are overlooked that lie outside the focus but still have a hazardous effect. Or the entire substance group is captured, which can be more or less harmful. The new methodology is more informative and improves our understanding of such complex products."
In most of the products studied, such as lipsticks, skincare creams, wound creams, and nipple creams, the scientists found relevant amounts of hazardous compounds that are not currently regulated. It is difficult to prove exactly what effect these hazardous compounds have on humans or the environment.
It is conceivable that they influence the skin microbiome and the body, especially if they enter the bloodstream directly through wounds, micro-cracks in the skin, which can occur, for example, when shaving, or bleeding gums. The hazardous compounds could also have effects on nature and the environment through washing off.
The new methodology also opens up possibilities to minimize the hazardous compounds in products: hazardous compounds discovered through combined sample separation and effect detection can efficiently be further investigated and even identified. This allows us to find out where these hazardous compounds come from and how they can be avoided in future products.
The analytical methodology is easy to integrate and implement. The JLU scientists also developed the cost-effective open-source 2LabsToGo-Eco, enabling manufacturers and authorities to better test and thus minimize exposure to hazardous compounds of lifestyle products, cosmetics, foods, feeds, and environmental samples in the future.
"Our studies also show that there are already some products that perform better today," says Prof. Morlock. "Products labeled as free from mineral oil residues contained comparatively fewer genotoxic and mutagenic mineral oil residues. Nevertheless, it is urgently necessary to act due to the large number of affected cosmetics and skincare products, which consumers usually use several times a day.
"One possibility would be the minimization concept, which continuously reduces hazardous compounds in the products and improves both consumer protection and environmental protection in the medium term."
More information: Gertrud E. Morlock, Chemical safety screening of products – better proactive, Journal of Chromatography A (2025).
Gertrud E. Morlock et al, Fast unmasking toxicity of safe personal care products, Journal of Chromatography A (2025).
Gertrud E. Morlock et al, Fast unmasking hazards of safe perfumes, Journal of Chromatography A (2025).
Maria C.O. Romero et al, Consolidating two laboratories into the most sustainable lab of the future: 2LabsToGo-Eco, Analytica Chimica Acta (2025).
Journal information: Analytica Chimica Acta
Provided by University of Giessen